Grading out the new Cougar uniforms
As you're probably aware by now, the new WSU football uniforms are out. And they are sleek, if not spectacular or particularly innovative.
Judging by the reaction on the Cougfan forums, most fans agree with me that the real thing is a disappointment compared to the EA Sports' version. The NCAA Football 10 version proves that once again EA doesn't care about getting details right unless your school is named USC or Oklahoma (or any other big name program, for that matter). First, the 'Cougars' script helmet is the home helmet, even though we're switching back to the Coug head. And even though the Coug head helmet is the primary, odds are you won't find it in the game, even though they included the one-time-only crimson 'Cougars' helmet used in last year's Apple Cup. At least the road helmet is right.
Next, EA fouled up the sleeve stripe by making it curved and not straight like what you see above. Not a big deal, and the video game version actually looks better in my opinion. Still, it's not accurate. Because, again, EA sports could care less about getting things accurate when dealing with a small market school.
Still, I guess you can't expect 100% accuracy from a video game. Let's talk about the real thing:
Helmets:
The home helmet is gray with the Coug head logo and a gray facemask. Perfect. I know a lot of people like the 'Cougars' script, but I'm not one of them. Grade: A+
The away helmet, oddly enough, is the same thing it's always been. Crimson with a white Coug head and white facemask. Since our school colors aren't Crimson and white, I've always felt the facemask and Coug head should be gray. I also think the crimson helmet should be scrapped in favor of a gray helmet on the road. Nevertheless, it still looks decent. Grade: B
Jerseys:
The '09 home jersey really isn't all that different from the '08. All Nike really did was make a single gray outline around the numbers and replace the sleeve numbers with a white stripe. The stripe looks like it cuts off way too early, and there's that weird gray cuff that runs all the way around even though the stripe above it doesn't. Weird. It will still look good on the field, but is it really an improvement over Russell? I'm not so sure. Although I do like the Coug head on the collar. Grade: B+
The away jersey is a definite improvement over the Russell jersey, if for no other reason than getting rid of those stupid crimson-outlined crimson numbers. Again, there's that weird gray cuff thing, but it's not very noticeable. Plus "Washington State" is on the front, so that drunk opposing fans (I'm looking at you, Autzen) don't confuse us with Stanford. Grade: A-
Pants:
Take a close look at the gray pants. You'll see a dark gray stripe. On gray pants. Does it make sense? Nope. Still, I'm always a fan of WSU wearing gray pants, either at home or on the road. Grade: B
The crimson pants, with a solid gray stripe, are perfect. Miles above the Russell candycane pants. Grade: A+
The white pants also have a gray stripe, which is weird because crimson would stand out more. It still looks good, though. Grade: A-
Shoes:
Black are better than white, but it doesn't matter too much to me. Grade: B
Overall (home):
Again, I really don't know if this is an improvement over Russell. At the moment, I'm not so sure. In reality the differences are so small it might not look all that different from the stands. Nike does make better quality jerseys, so at least the recruits will like that. Still, I'm underwhelmed. They're good, but not great. Grade: B+
Overall (away):
By taking away a lot of the stuff that used to annoy me, Nike makes a better road jersey for us. The all-white combo looks good too, although Nike already rolled out the same concept for UW earlier this Spring. I like the white-crimson combo much better than the old version. It's still missing out on greatness, but it's closer than we've been in quite some time. I'm thinking that if I pick up a replica at Crimson and Gray, this will be the one. Grade: A-
Now I turn the question over to you, Coug Nation. What do you think?
0 recs |
11 comments
|
Comments
New Uniforms
Awesome write up on the new uniforms,
I know there’s a lot of gripe about the logo vs. script on the helmet (I prefer script, but I’m good either way). But way more importantly, isn’t it just time to give up the crimson helmet altogether? There is nothing WSUish about it, it looks like OU, its not traditional, and it seems entirely unnecessary, especially if “brand recognition” is a catch phrase with the new uniforms. Why not just stick with our traditional lid and mix in the script every now and again (Apple Cup)?
Go Cougs
by LACoug on Jun 15, 2009 2:13 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I like the concept of a crimson helmet
But when it fails to match the color of the pants accurately, it annoys the tar out of me. Reminds me of when the UW used to have purple helmets and purple shirts. It’s just impossible to get the color just right.
by Jeff Nusser on Jun 15, 2009 3:23 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
The biggest improvement for me
Is the road uniform. I hated those “candy-cane” pants we had. They looked terrible on television. It seemed like the shade of crimson differed from the home jerseys as well.
Also, our football players are tiny.
I never really liked the old tagline.
CougCenter
by Dancing Football on Jun 15, 2009 2:21 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Agree on most stuff
Wulff did mention at the tailgate that WSU was the first team to use a duel helmet scheme so I think that is one reason they are keeping both. I do agree that the EA version looked better than the unis and I saw them in person. I am glad they are going with the logo on the helmets though. As you said, the stripe is straight and cut off and then the gray stripe is the elastice and gets rolled under the shoulder pads so you can’t even see it. Once again Nike is way too red and I even think the numbers are more red than the stripe or pants. I do think Russell had a better Crimson.
Overall I like them, but liked the video game version a little better. the replicas just have two stripes on the end of the sleeves so don’t seem like something I really need to pick up as I already have a nike replica of last years jersey. The only thing that would make me want to pick up a replica jersey is if they come out with a gray jersey, which I hope they do. The pants are way better in my opinion, though I agree the gray pants need a crimson stripe.
http://wsufoundation.wsu.edu/giving/enteramount.asp?Fund=Martin%20Stadium%20Project
by selahcoug on Jun 15, 2009 3:25 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Add the stripe to the silver pants for sure...
and diamond plating to the shoulders.
"The brownies,'' Fernandez said after the game. "The brownies are good for me to make three-points.''
- from Quick's Behind the Blazers Locker Room Door, 4/16/09
by ArbyOSU on Jun 15, 2009 4:41 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
you mean like the Ducks? No thanks, they can keep their ugly uniform scheme (god knows the colors are already bad enough lol). Keep it simple, adding flash like that distracts from player numbers and school logos.
by Bleezz on Jun 28, 2009 10:23 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Not bad.
You guys made a similar change to our improvements last year, going with a very clean, simple look. I like it, except the “Ohio State Fan Club” outfit on the far left should not be worn together like that.
Oh, and thank you for NOT adding an all black uniform.
I say B+, maybe even an A-?
"The brownies,'' Fernandez said after the game. "The brownies are good for me to make three-points.''
- from Quick's Behind the Blazers Locker Room Door, 4/16/09
by ArbyOSU on Jun 15, 2009 4:40 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
It should be, "...EA sports COULDN'T care less..."
Sorry, pet peeve.
by brlogan on Jun 15, 2009 5:08 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I agree. Gray facemask.
Grady, I also think they should use a gray facemask with the crimson helment. I think it would look a lot better. I agree we are crimson and gray, not crimson and white. The white facemask stands out to much. The gray facemask just seems more rugged, old school (throwback) and classy. The white facemask just screams bush league to me. A lot of teams are starting to wear the gray facemask, or are going back to their original gray facemask or have always had the gray facemask. i.e. Giants, Colts, Alabama, USC, and 49ers. LOSE the white facemask. This isn’t the CFL. Sorry, CFL fans about your league, nothing personal.
by SoCalCoug on Jun 16, 2009 7:36 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I love the new uni’s….
Cougar Patrick
Check out my blog at boarderwars.blogspot.com
by Cougar_Patrick on Jun 16, 2009 7:51 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Why hate on EA?
Hey Grady, good read on the uni’s. I think I like them as much as you, in the A- category. I think the gray looks a little dull, but then again maybe it’s still a little too early to judge? We’ve only see them from EA and now on a stage inside an arena. We haven’t seen them in action, outdoors, where everyone is wearing the same thing. They might look a lot better this fall. But I like the clean and modern look overall.
On the EA criticism, seriously, why hate on them? Do you actually think they really don’t care if they get things right? Not to be some sort of apologist for them (and believe me, I’m not!), but they are only at the mercy of the respective school’s SID, and whatever they provide for uni specs. They were using whatever WSU gave them based on specs from several months ago, but things might have changed slightly in these final versions. I think it’s easy to rip EA, but getting uni’s 100% right for 119 D-1 schools is probably tougher for graphic artists than we might think.
by Sean Hawkins on Jun 16, 2009 10:21 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs

by 








