A quick analysis of Emerson Murray - and what he potentially represents
As we passed along earlier, Cougfan.com is reporting that the Cougs are reportedly looking at Emerson Murray, a 6-3 combo guard from British Columbia, to fill one of the scholarships vacated in the last week. Since he hasn't committed -- or apparently even been offered -- I'm not going to go too in depth into analyzing him. But I think his recruitment in general might give us a little insight.
The good thing about Murray is that there is literally a load of Youtube video out there on him. This first video shows off his athleticism. He reportedly injured his ankle sometime this past season, but this video is from last summer -- before the injury:
Now, I'm never an enormous fan of using videos like this to create a cast-in-stone evaluation, because basketball is so much more than a series of isolated clips. I mean, if you took a series of Reggie Moore's highlights from this year, you'd conclude he was one of the top point guards in the country. He was very good most of the time, but he also has some serious flaws in his game that he needs to work on -- flaws that wouldn't show up in a video such as this. So I'm not going to take this thing as gospel.
That said ... this is pretty awesome. It's obvious the competition isn't the greatest, but that explosion off the floor is good against anyone. Quickness-wise, it's tough to tell what he's really got, again because of the competition, but it seems decent.
This is the second video. It's more of the same, apparently recorded during a similar time frame, but I like this one because we get a better look at his jumper, which shows up multiple times:
Really nice form on that jumper. Will it translate to the college level? Tough to say because he doesn't generally shoot under duress in any of these clips. He's generally being guarded by guys who are shorter. But it does give you some confidence that he could knock down an open 3, which is a nice skill.
In total, a really nice package of a player if there are no lingering effects from his ankle injury. He's long, athletic, and ostensibly is precisely the sort of player Ken Bone wants -- he seems to be able to get to the rim and shoot from outside equally well. While he doesn't exactly have the ball on a string, he looks like he could competently hold down the point guard spot for stretches. He actually looks a lot like Marcus Capers with a jumper, if that makes sense.
I find it a little curious, though, that he hasn't been offered a scholarship by Bone. This leads me to one of two conclusions:
- He's not as good of a basketball player as he looks against mediocre competition.
- Bone has someone better on his radar and is holding out for him.
My guess? It's probably a little bit of both. Murray reportedly only holds scholarship offers from a couple of mid-majors -- although one is St. Mary's, which ought to make you sit up a little and take notice -- which suggests he might not be as good as he appears. This could be chalked up either to inherent lack of elite talent or (as Coug Friendly Canuck suggests and I would tend to agree with) perhaps a lack of development from the weaker competition up north. He might just need a little bit of seasoning, which is why it wouldn't surprise me if Bone was targeting someone a little more Pac-10 ready, especially with our immediate need for another competent ball handler.
In either case the news that the Cougs are on Murray's trail should excite you. If we land someone better, that's fantastic. If we end up with Emerson, we've landed a recruit who looks like he's got loads of potential. Not a bad place to be.
I've embedded more video in a playlist after the jump. The first is a video that you'll just want to skip the first 20 seconds. Trust me, it's worth it after that.
17 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
You can't teach athleticism
I know he is playing against lesser competition, but you can tell this kid is athletic. A lot of times with athleticism you have great potential. I think he is pretty raw and Bone can mold him into a pretty good player. You talk about how he is shooting over shorter players, so you really can’t tell how that will translate to Pac10 pay, but he has the spring to get up quick and get a jump shot off before he is blocked. I loved Thames, but that is one thing I noticed about his game. He only jumped about 3" when he took a jump shot. Most of the time he needed separation to get his shot off. People with hops can tend to create shots easier (but you also have to have the skill to shoot). Capers is a perfect example of the opposite of that. I love Capers, but we got to improve that jump shot.
member of CougCenter since 9/2/08
He may be a good candidate for a redshirt
Give him some time to work on skills while filling in a class that we will be lacking scholarships for
If we're going to have to RS him
We may as well not offer him. Unfortunately we’re going to need a guard that can play now to add depth at the guard spot, I think.
a plea to cougar nation
please stop asking for basketball players to redshirt. it rarely makes sense.
Would have been nice for Bjornstad though.
The very little time he got, was not worth losing the year of eligibility. A bad move by Bone I thought. I think he was worried about depth of the posts early on, but Bjornstad just wasn’t ready physically yet.
Was it, though?
Would you rather have a project clog your roster for 4 years or 5? I’m really not so sure, especially since I think he had a pretty good idea of some roster slots opening up to create balance.
I’ve actually got a list of redshirts over the last 5+ or so years. It isn’t pretty for the most part.
You also have to remember
That the decision to burn Bjornstad’s RS was very early in the season when there was a chance Watson’s career was over. Bone had to have someone else ready to back up Casto, Einquist alone wasn’t going to cut it.
by gbob on Apr 1, 2010 9:55 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Agree completely
In football the year of working out can make a big difference in strength and growth in things that translate to the field, especially with linemen. And with 85 possible scholarships, carrying a project or two that doesn’t pan out can go unnoticed. In football, the majority of time is taken up by maybe 46 players (2 deep plus 2 kickers). That is 54% of your scholarships.
Basketball gets 13. Under Bone’s ideal rotation at least 9 guys will see consistent time, and he would probably like to have 10 he is comfortable with. Ten 77% of the free rides. Even if you just look at 8 guys playing important minutes, your at 62%. What I am really getting at is that while it is possible for a player to be buried at the end of the bench for a year or two, eventually they have to contribute to make the scholarship worthwhile or they will likely be out. Getting stronger and bigger is important in basketball, but not to the degree it is in football. Being able to cope with the speed of play is more important. Redshirting doesn’t tell a coach as much as limited minutes might.
Redshirts in basketball are used for guys to transfer. We are seeing that now, and we’ll see it in the future. But redshirting players, especially guards that live and die with their ability to play at Pac 10 speed, is not a great strategy. On some level there are either signs that a player can play in the Pac 10 or signs that they can’t.
Great thoughts.
Another thing people don’t often consider: A lot of coaches leave it up to the player. Sometimes you get more out of a guy in practice when he believes he’s got a chance to play. But let’s assume this was Bone’s decision alone. Again, you tell a guy to practice like he’s going to play, because he’s one DeAngelo Casto sprained ankle away from playing 10-15 minutes in the next game.
Hindsight is 20/20. There were no injuries this year to a major player. Not even one. Can you remember a year when that happened?
Woo! Shoutout for me!
I’d be perfectly happy if the Cougs signed Emerson, as long as no one is expecting him to be the key in the Cougars making a run to the Elite 8 or something next year. He’s athletic enough that he could play some minutes, but he’ll definitely need some “seasoning.”
He definitely has more potential than the Cougs’ last Canuck, Shami Gill.
by Coug Friendly Canuck on Apr 1, 2010 10:26 PM PDT reply actions
With the GU players as well
The “seasoning” comment seems to apply even though some of their players are long and physical.
Murray seems to have potential but I don’t know if he give Bone what he needs right now.
Time will tell.
Yeah, those 3 kids are all really talented.
But Sacre never got the ball in high school. The guards he played with in high school (including the Kepkay kid from Utah) had NO interest in getting the big kid the ball (and their coach for some reason didn’t care). Not sure how much it would have helped his development to get more touches anyhow; not like there’s much anybody up here is going to be able to do much about an athletic 7 footer.
Kong played at the same high school as Emerson, then played a year of awful quasi-JUCO ball up here on a really stacked team, then had to sit out a year while his visa got worked out. He didn’t really get much coaching at either school. His high school team played a 3-2 zone with him standing around resting all the time on D (unless he felt like trying to run through the passing lane to try and get a steal and a cheap dunk). They pretty much just gave him the ball on O. It’ll be really interesting to see how much he improves with a full off-season in Spokane; he’s very talented.
I coached against Olynyk in my last year coaching when he was in Grade 10. At that time he was a skinny 6’4" kid that my best defender was absolutely able to dominate. Next I saw him was at the provincial tournament when he was in Grade 12; in the meantime he’d broken his arm playing football and grown 6 inches. I thought he was one of the softest high school kids I’d ever seen there, but he really surprised me with how well he did at Gonzaga this year.
An exception to this trend might be the Trasolini kid at Santa Clara (who I’d hoped the Cougs would recruit). He put up pretty good numbers right away, but he’s a much more physically mature kid. Again though, he played for a high school team that had terrible guards that never gave him the ball.
Anyhow, a lot of information about guys that don’t play for the Cougs, but it illustrates some of the limitations kids face playing up here. Emerson’s really talented, but Pac-10 play will probably show some major holes in his game, at least in the short term.
by Coug Friendly Canuck on Apr 2, 2010 8:35 AM PDT up reply actions
his game reminds me of reggie
The main thing that I noticed in the few videos I watched is he seems comfortable handling the ball and can consistently make a quick move to get around his man (or create some space for a jumper). If you are basically looking for somebody to force tempo, give Moore a blow, or cause some havic on the defensive end (traps, playing the lanes, etc.), I think he is the right type.
If we got him, I would be interested in seeing Moore, Murray, and Capers on the court at the same time. He appears to have quick hands like both Moore and Capers, so the 3 of them could force some turnovers for a 2-3 minute stretch while Klay and Aiden (sic?) are resting their jumpers!
by LeaveItToWeaver on Apr 2, 2010 12:32 AM PDT reply actions
Guard Requirement
Maybe too little too late for Bone!

by 













